Art as Provocation

Getting Noticed

In my post, Blogging for Profit, I lamented on the clamour for publicity in the desire for money and profit. I emphasized the nefarious ways websites and magazines generate reader clicks and subscriptions.

There are also legitimate ways to get noticed. If the quality of the product is excellent, and the service is required, a business should succeed. The same is true in art.

Paying to Survive

The business of art requires profits. Professional artists need to sell their work to earn a living. Art galleries need to earn a commission on sales to keep operating. Museums and public galleries need customers to pay for their infrastructure. Publicity is required to induce patrons and customers to view art and make purchases.

How do artists become known? Let’s look at some famous artists.

Provocation in Art

One way to become famous is to be provocative. Over the centuries artists achieved prominence by provoking society to see art and culture in new ways.

Classical painting previously painted the ruling and upper classes, mythic gods and religious narratives. Gustave Courbet and Eduoard Manet painted ordinary people (even prostitutes) as legitimate subject matter, shocking public sensibilities.

Manet’s Olympia

The Impressionist and the Expressionist painters broke convention by painting in unrealistic colours and distorting perspective. This shocked and upset many art patrons and public sensibilities.

Picasso broke the picture into cubes, and the Fauves used garish colours in their compositions. Picasso created disturbing, ugly paintings to convey the horrors of warfare.

Pablo Picasso

Rene Magritte, Marcel Duchamp and Philip Guston disrupted the conventions of what constitutes art.

These paintings provoked the viewer into uncomfortable emotions and outrage. They upset cultural sensibilities. They created art which did not evoke skill, inspiration, or beauty.

Getting Attention

Thus urge to provoke and upset continues today. Some artists are at the forefront of social change, confronting racism, women’s rights, injustice, and any and every social norm.

As we become more inured to what is shocking, each generation of artists finds more outrageous ways to provoke. We have human portraits sculpted from frozen blood, huge sharks preserved in glass tanks of formaldehyde, canned human excrement, or a banana taped to a gallery wall.

Do we have to go to further extremes to get publicity? Hopefully we can look elsewhere for the answer.

Finding Provocation

As artists and creators how can we be provocative? Being provocative means pushing ourselves to be more expressive, more introspective, more sensitive to our discourse while keeping true to ourselves and our values.

The essence of art making is to create a reaction in ourselves and the viewer that goes way beyond ‘meh’.

Learning to Provoke

In art school our art projects stimulated creativity and pushed us to find our visual voice. The studio creations showed how unique each student could be. Critiques and evaluations provided valuable feedback on what was effective and what was deficient.

Art school helped me to be provocative and expressive. An example is a portrait of Marcel Duchamp I painted (below). My objective was to provoke the provoker by mocking his urinal sculpture (note the little turds and urinal).

I realize this was just an art school joke about my belief that a urinal is not art.

Art should be more than a contrived Look at me!” or “See how clever I am”.

Taboos

Provocation can also be accidental. For example nudity is a topic with the potential to be misinterpreted. For some audiences it is a taboo and can be mistaken for pornography.

I enjoy drawing the human figure. I want to show its grace and beauty. Is my drawing provocative and titillating to the viewer for purient reasons?

Am I using nudity for shock? Certainly with society’s sensitivity to equality and gender issues, a male artist drawing a female may be considered inappropriate and his art no longer legitimate. Should I only draw male nudes? Or unattractive nudes? I don’t know the answer.

Other taboo subjects that can be provocative include portraying religious and political beliefs or deeply held social conventions. Using Nazi symbols, mocking God, or Buddha, showing sexual acts, or vivid scenes of carnage are all provocative and socially taboo. An artist who invokes these topics should expect or welcome controversy and ostracism.

Banksy showing an iconic image from Vietnam war with Mickey and Ronald MacDonald

As an activist, Banksy uses art as a way to raise awareness and protest against current issues such as climate change, military conflicts, and poverty.

Diggit Magazine

Authentic Provocation

The word ‘provoke’ is itself provoking. Other words may better describe what our incentive should be. We want to ‘instill’ or ‘inspire’ or ‘evoke’ or ‘reveal’ or ‘awaken’ something in the viewer. When we have created something special or meaningful, we want to offer it to an audience.

We want our creation to be authentic to who we are, what we see, what we feel, what we believe, what really moves us. If publicity has any value we want the publicity to further our reputation. We want our name aligned with the art we create.

In my last year of art school each graduate created a body of work for public viewing. The artists’ statements offer insight into the motivations, intentions and framework behind the shows. This is what provokes the artist.

Here is part of my artist statement for my graduate show: “Public Place, Private Space”

My cityscape paintings portray settings which create ambivalent and contradictory feelings, such as inspiration and intimidation, freedom and confinement. Does the city offer beauty or brutality, utility or complexity, ease or anxiety? These paintings look at the confusions and contradictions created within people and places by modern technology.

Ron Kuwahara

The paintings below convey the effect of cityscapes on its citizens.

These painting align with my intentions and helps me to build the reputation that I want. I want to be known as an artist who cares about the well-being of the ordinary citizen.

Summary

Art needs to create a reaction in the viewer, some works are provocative, some are subtle, some are subliminal. When an artist finds that ‘buzz’, the work and the resultant publicity is successful. It assists the artist in building a reputation and a viewership.

When I’m at my best, I’m trying to destabilize myself and figure out new ways of approaching art as a provocation. I think I am at my best when I push myself into a place where I don’t have all the answers.

Kehinde Wiley

Art is the provocation for talking about enigma and the search for sense in human life. One can do that by telling a story or writing about a fresco by Giotto or studying how a snail climbs up a wall.

John Berger

Vienna: Part 2

MONUMENT AGAINST WAR AND FASCISM

Just a Tourist

In this post I review Vienna as a tourist, and then delve into Vienna’s history.

I traveled to Vienna as a tourist with little prior knowledge of Austria, its history or its culture. I met my son in Vienna as he was completing a multi- month tour of Eastern Europe. We stayed in a modest AirBnB apartment 2 km from the city centre (Innere Stadt).

Google and the Internet provided the maps, guides, and translations we required to plan and organize our excursions. We used the public transportation network of subways, trams, and buses for our travels. It was efficient, low cost and easy to use. We walked extensively throughout the city

Cafe Central

We ate street food and fancier meals at iconic Viennese restaurants. We indulged in the art, music and museum scene as discussed in the previous post.

Personal Encounters

I have only praise for Vienna and its citizens. Our main interactions with the Viennese were with our AirBnB host, the numerous waiters, shopkeepers and tour guides. They were all helpful and respectful. We mingled with regular citizens of various ethnicities while shopping in markets, sitting on trams or relaxing in parks. We enjoyed the musicians and dancers.

The city felt efficient, clean, safe and welcoming. I would highly recommend a visit to this beautiful city.

Vienna Beyond Tourism

Of course Vienna is far more than a beautiful tourist attraction. A city as old as Vienna contains innumerable layers of politics, history and culture. Vienna experienced centuries of immigration, conquest, assimilation, expansion, exploitation, victories and defeats, creating the city that exists today. While I am an avid reader of European history, I don’t know enough to offer a meaningful perspective on Vienna’s history. A moral and ethical assessment depends on who evaluates the outcomes.

Anschluss

A period of history often lost to the tourist is the role that Austria played prior to World War II.

On March 11–13, 1938, Nazi Germany annexed the neighboring country of Austria (Österreich). This event is known as the Anschluss. “Anschluss” is a German word that means “connection” or “joining.”

Google

City Hall and the Hofburg Palace

A visitor to … the curved colonnaded Neue Burg wing of Vienna’s imperial Hofburg Palace, can walk right up to doors that lead to one of the most infamous balconies in Austrian history: the site of Adolf Hitler’s speech on March 15, 1938, in which he announced to cheering Austrians that his birth country had been incorporated into the Third Reich, an event known as the Anschluss. Yet the doors stay closed, making it impossible for a visitor to step out onto what is sometimes called the “Hitler balcony.”

Google dw.com

Was Austria complicit in sustaining the atrocities of Nazi Germany? Should Vienna be condemned for its role? While I unequivocally condemn Nazism and Fascism, my judgment of Vienna is less clear.

I cannot condemn Vienna for its darker history, unless I am willing to offer a similar judgment on my own behaviour. I have certainly ignored or harmed others (perhaps inadvertently) in the pursuit of my own goals. Some victories have meant defeat for my rivals. I have applauded leaders who supported my beliefs, and I have formed alliances that I have later regretted. I have turned a blind eye to suffering, and I have ignored pleas for aid. I have avoided conflict where righteous action was needed. Is a city history any different my personal history?

Indeed the reasons I love Vienna and reasons I dislike Vienna are the very values that I love and hate about myself.

Let him who is without sin cast the first stone,”

Bible. John 8:7.

Accepting Responsibility

Monument Against War and Fascism

The opinions of today’s Viennese citizens are far more legitimate than mine. It is important that Vienna’s role in the Anschluss is being acknowledged and not denied. Vienna has built the Monument Against War and Fascism on Albertinaplatz, behind Vienna’s Opera House to acknowledge victims of war and violence, and the 65000 Viennese Jews who died in concentration camps.

Conquest and Exploitation

Vienna played a key role in many world-changing events. The whole history of the Austro-Hungarian Empire must hold some dark chapters. Consider the Napoleonic Wars, World War I and colonization. Do the Vienna museums and galleries display the spoils of war and political conquest?

Welt Museum

A partial answer was provided in a notice at the entrance to the Welt Museum (World Ethnographic Museum)

Aztec Headdress

Most of the world’s population was dominated by foreign powers in the years between 1500 and 1920. This foreign rule was defined by conflicts and exploitation. Against this backdrop, ethnographic museums flourished in the 19th and 20th centuries and shaped stereotypical beliefs of lost or colonised cultures. As our Museum was one of those benefitting from Europe’s colonial expansion, the stories behind many objects and how they were acquired deal with appropriation and colonial violence.

Although the colonies gradually fought for and were granted their independence after World War Il, it was as if time stood still in ethnographic museums. The cherished and seemingly timeless conceptions of “us” and “them” were only hesitantly challenged as late as in the 1980s.

Today we face our colonial past not only to raise awareness but also to learn from it. After all, how we deal with our collections and the people related to them in the present will shape the image of ethnographic collections in the future.”

Vienna Welt Museum

Notorious Artist

In his 1925 autobiography Mein Kampf, Adolf Hitler described how, in his youth, he wanted to become a professional artist, but his dreams were ruined because he failed the entrance exam of the Academy of Fine Arts Vienna. Hitler was rejected twice by the institute, once in 1907 and again in 1908.

Google

A tour guide told us that Adolf Hitler hated Vienna after he was rejected by the art academy. The guide suggested World War II may have been drastically different had Hitler been accepted into art school and became an artist.

Should we blame Vienna for Hitler’s conversion to politics? Should we applaud Vienna for maintaining high artistic standards? Here is a painting by Adolf Hitler. Judge for yourself.

Wikimedia

Adolf Hitler: Alpenhof

Nobody is Perfect

Each of us is a mixture of good qualities,
and some not so good qualities.
In considering our fellow man we should remember his good qualities, and realize
his faults only prove that he is, after all a human being.
We should refrain from making harsh judgment of a person just because he happens to be
A Dirty Rotten
No Good
Son of a Bitch!

(Anonymous)

and a ruthless, evil, mass murderer and war criminal

Blogging for Fame

What is the Price for Fame?

My secret ambition when I started this blog was to reach a large audience. I had visions of blogging to hundreds or thousands of readers. People around the world would ask “what did Ron write about today?” A Google search of a topic in art or aging would quickly lead to this blog. Fame and fortune would soon follow.

This desire was very naive and troubling.

Publicize or Languish

This vision of having a large readership can be ethically dangerous. The quest for fame is akin to the quest for higher profit: more readers, more subscriptions, more clicks, and more money!

To be famous and rich on the web, creating publicity is far more important than writing posts. It is tempting to find ways to ‘go viral’ to get readers.

Tempting Headlines

Here are some ways newspapers and websites create publicity and attention.

Fake News, False Facts

False information and fake news proliferate on the internet. People write almost anything to get noticed.

Provoke Controversy

If fake news doesn’t work, news channels use outrageous provocation to press our hot buttons to get us upset. The tabloids and their prominent columnists peddle sensational and controversial opinions. Their rhetoric instills curiosity and outrage.

News and information are becoming so biased and opinionated that we are wary of any information provided by the web. Facts and truth get lost to emotional reactions. Websites that provide factual information in a unbiased and rational manner are often overlooked and hard to find.

Stupidity and Misfortune

Writers provoke our curiosity by revealing the stupidity or misfortune of others.

Free Stuff or Easy Cheats

Other headlines tell us how to get more from less, to get more clicks on a webpage.

Catastrophizing Life

Headlines tell us what’s wrong with people, society or the world to get our attention.

it is a tale told by an idiot, full of sound and fury, signifying nothing.”

Macbeth, William Shakespeare

My Headlines

Based on these tried and true techniques to grab attention, I should create provocative headlines to attract readers.

Ron’s headlines as clickbait.

He shared what he had with poor peasants

Make 10,000 paintings and sell them for $100
Don’t eat arsenic oil paint

Food for Thought

It’s not surprising that many industries are putting profits ahead of the quality of products they produce. If people can be persuaded to pay more money for a fancier product than why not? Give them what they think they want. It’s usually short term pleasure over long term value.

Much of the food industry tempts people to buy products with promises of more flavour, sweeter taste, easy preparation, quicker cooking, or lower prices.

We can’t be sustained by fancy packaging and instant gratification. It’s no wonder we have an ongoing worldwide health crisis.

We require nutrition that promotes health and well-being. Wholesome food may not be so profitable to the manufacturer, but it will have far more benefit to the consumer.

No! No! No!

Similarly a blog needs to omit the bombast of outrageousness and shock. It needs to offer sustenance with a deeper level of satisfaction.

I am unwilling to provoke publicity just to entice more readers. I would rather have a small faithful readership who selects substance over frivolity. This blog will provide sincere and engaging content without sensationalizing the information.

Information is not knowledge, and knowledge is not wisdom. Reading – even browsing – an old book can yield sustenance denied by a database search. Patience is a virtue, gluttony a sin.”

James Gleick